"In Taiwan, only about 35% of the 500,000 Austronesian indigenous people can speak their tribal language.
Many people in their 40s and 50s can't speak their mother-tongue, so they can't teach it to the younger generation. The younger people also think 'I'm fine if I can speak Mandarin and English; learning indigenous languages doesn't help me increase my competitiveness'."
The decline of the languages of the island's more than 14 tribes did not happen by accident...
- Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
- Public Discussion (3)
It makes me sad to think of people getting punished for speaking their natural mother tongue. Of course this isn't confined to Taiwan - the sentiment is disturbingly similar across countries that have been colonised.
- 3 votes
Language loss is always sad. Globally - in both senses of the word - it makes for a less interesting world, especially because, as you mention, language is almost inextricably linked to culture and self-identity.
And I don't say this to be harsh, but unfortunately language loss is a fact of existence. Pidgins become creoles becomes languages, they change, they die. "Circle of life." And while certainly efforts can - and perhaps should - be made to prolong this inevitability as long as possible, it simply cannot be stopped. Indeed, languages die of "natural causes" if I may use this term to contrast the situation in the article.
While the loss of the language itself is, on one hand, a tragedy, the true tragedy is the reason for which it is being lost...
It makes me sad to think of people getting punished for speaking their natural mother tongue.
This - the explicit and hateful denial of a primary language - is the true tragedy. It is a form of oppression, and it hits at the heart of individuals. Certainly because, as briefly mentioned, languages do die "of natural causes," we can mourn a loss of a language, but we cannot prevent it. We can prevent oppressive governments who wish to control - in essence - identity.
Since I study Spanish I am always reminded of Spain under Franco when linguistic oppression is mentioned. I suppose the fact that, despite his treatment of the other Spanish languages, they survived him, and some in fact thrived because of him. In contrast to the situation in the seeded article, sometimes nothing induces pride and a resurgence of a language more than to tell people they can't speak it, as in Franco's Spain; the speakers of Catalan, e.g., - although underground until it became "legal" again - only spoke it, wrote in it, and sang in it more because of Franco. I always laugh at that fact.
- 3 votes
the true tragedy is the reason for which it is being lost...the explicit and hateful denial of a primary language
You've hit the nail directly on the head - I agree that language loss can be inevitable but when it's backed by a campaign of prejudice then people need to speak out (excuse the pun)!
I did not know that about Catalan but great to see the widespread support. With numbers people pay more attention, but every language has a special status.
- 1 vote
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |



